top of page

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Search

DON BRASH: IS RACISM JUSTIFIED IN THE HEALTH SECTOR?

I’ve just read a depressing defence of the Government’s policy of prioritizing Maori and Pasifika when it comes to surgical waiting lists. It was written by one Will Trafford and published by Te Ao Maori News.


As background, most readers will recall that it was revealed in the New Zealand Herald of 19 June that Health New Zealand (or Te Whatu Ora as they prefer to be known) has introduced “an Equity Adjustor Score” intended to “reduce inequity in the system by using an algorithm to prioritise patients according to clinical priority, time spent on the waitlist, geographic location (isolated areas), ethnicity, and deprivation level”.


In the “ethnicity category”, Maori and Pasifika are top of the list, with all other ethnicities lower-ranked.


There has been strong push-back against using ethnicity as the basis for determining priority for surgery, from at least some surgeons, and from both the National Party and ACT.


Mr Trafford offers four arguments in defence of the system.


First, he argues that “Maori experience poorer health outcomes than non-Maori, for no fault of their own”. He notes that “Maori have higher rates of chronic conditions such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes and respiratory diseases.”


Second, he notes that “Maori have a lower life expectancy than non-Maori”.


Third, he argues that “Maori face barriers in accessing healthcare services, leading to delays in receiving appropriate treatment”.


And finally, he argues that “the New Zealand government has a commitment to equitable participation in healthcare for Maori through Te Tiriti o Waitangi”.


The first three of those arguments don’t carry water at all. If, as he asserts, probably correctly, Maori have poorer outcomes than other New Zealanders, they will by definition be getting more access to surgery given that clinical priority, time spent on the waitlist, geographic location (isolated areas) and deprivation are already key criteria in determining who gets priority access to surgery. There is absolutely no reason to add ethnicity on those three grounds.


David Seymour asked the Prime Minister in Parliament on Tuesday this week whether he would be considered Maori for the purposes of receiving healthcare, and was told that that was up to him. (Mr Seymour has some Ngapuhi ancestry.) As Mr Seymour commented: “That settles the question of how Te Whatu Ora determines whether someone is Maori, Pasifika, or another ethnicity for the purposes of prioritizing people on the surgical waitlist. You can just self-identify.”


It is Mr Trafford’s fourth argument for prioritizing Maori and Pasifika which is the weakest. He argues that Te Tiriti requires the government to provide “equitable participation in healthcare for Maori”. (Te Tiriti said nothing about Pasifika of course.) And he is surely right that Article III of Te Tiriti made it clear that all New Zealanders were to have equal rights and responsibilities, but equal rights cannot be interpreted to mean superior rights for those who chance to have one or more Maori ancestors.


If clinical priority, time spent on the waiting list, living in a remote area and deprivation level are used as criteria in ordering the waiting list, those with a Maori or Pasifika ancestor may on average get a degree of priority, but that should have nothing whatsoever to do with who their ancestors were.


Don Brash

20 June 2023




3,215 views136 comments

136 Comments


You are stating the obvious that those with poorer health get better health care. Your logic is that New Zealanders with poorer outcomes than other New Zealanders get more access to surgery given they meet the key criteria in determining who gets priority access to surgery. Māori are New Zealanders so they must already be getting priority.


Indeed that is true, but you haven’t addressed the question of whether Maori with poorer outcomes are getting equal treatment with non Māori who have the same poorer outcomes. The research says they are not, however there has been great effort to improve Māori health, and that benefits us all, Māori and non Māori alike

Like

Surgeon Maxine Ronald whose speciality is breast cancer says that ”what people don’t understand is that we’ve always prioritised for ethnicity. The system is designed to privilege Pākehā, as it was designed for and by them. It works for Pākehā and it’s why they live longer, do better, have better outcomes in all categories.…We know that ethnicity, by itself, is an independent risk factor for poor health outcomes.”

Maxine concludes “it feels like we’re wasting our time having to explain all these things over and over to people who aren’t willing to listen or learn.” Don Brash feels Māori don’t deserve better health because they shouldn’t receive superior rights. Māori want equal healthcare rights, not superior rights. Listen an…


Like
Replying to

I suggest that you take your own advice.

Like

Like many thinking Kiwis, I'm both wary and weary of the relentless new narratives of Māori exceptionalism and need. It seems that our experience of being born-here tangata Kiwis is subject to constant reframing in Māori nationalist perspectives.


That said, there is no denying the sorry health statistics of Māori and Polynesians. What makes them ill and diseased drags us all down. We'd all be better off if they were healthy.


Our current pre-occupation with Māori stats tends to obscure though that many more Kiwis of other ancestry are in similar distress and comparable need.


We also deny the evidence that this distress is a consequence of poverty. And guess what? That poverty originates in - indeed, is considered t…


Like
Replying to

Well said. You can take a horse to water but you can't make it drink. I loathe injustice but I'm heartily sick of the " Poor me, " Victim mentality.

Like

Robyn Hutchison
Robyn Hutchison
Jun 23, 2023

It is disgusting the depths to which this government has stooped. These people have proven themselves to be both morally and ethically bankrupt! First, I do not accept that we have a population split of Maori and Pakeha anymore. There has been so much intermingling of bloodlines and cultures that the difference now is barely detectable. Secondly, if we must determine those who identify as Maori as a separate group, they have the same lifestyle choices to make as anyone else, which will either support or jeopardise their health. Perhaps if corporate iwi were to actually share with their own people their ill-gotten gains from the government-enabled gravy train, there might be resources available to support wellness centres and …

Like

What can one say, I live in an isolated situation, I am not poor, but neither rich, at the moment I am waiting for an appointment, re a biopsy concerning my prostate, that biopsy was suppose to have been early this month, but no, I am on a waiting list, that wait could be 4 maybe 5 months, so sorry, I forgot to mention that I am white.

Like
Replying to

You privileged white devil ?????????

Like
bottom of page