top of page

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Search

JOHN RAINE: International Education – Not just a Question of Re-opening the Border

The 20th March NZ Herald article, “Hundreds of International students affected by visa delays”, does not reassure us that specialist capacity issues in Immigration New Zealand have been addressed. These were well known at least two years ago as international student business was re-opening.


Covid-19 lockdowns and the border closure caused massive destruction to our tourism and hospitality industries, but also widespread damage to many other industries, notably international education.


So, how significant was this? Between the early 1990s and 2019, New Zealand built up a remarkably successful international student business.  This spanned secondary school students, English language courses, polytechnic and other tertiary diplomas, undergraduate degrees, Master’s degrees and PhDs.  In 2019, over 117,000 enrolled students delivered the country a total economic benefit of around $5Bn.  Leaving off the wider economic benefits of having these students in New Zealand, tertiary sector base international revenue was ~$1.5Bn or ~1.8% of NZ exports of goods and services.  


University international 2019 student fee revenue was about $600m, or around 15% of universities’ total revenue.  International students pay up to five times the domestic student fee rate. For example, at AUT, where I worked in 2019, international students made up 18% of the student body but delivered about 48% of student fee income.


With this proportion of annual revenue coming from international enrolments, Universities were always vulnerable to not meeting the Tertiary Education Commission requirement that they generate a 3% financial surplus.


Covid-19 dramatically reduced the number of international students studying within New Zealand, partly replaced by students enrolled for on-line studies. Mid-2020, universities faced a year-end financial shortfall from lost international enrolments of about $200m, and this was expected to rise to $400m in 2021.  On-line enrolments softened the expected impact, but the consequences were massive, with substantial staff losses more recently across several institutions.


There was little apparent concern from the last Government about the sudden interruption to the flow of international students, but there were several consequent issues that needed consideration in 2021-2022. While, by early 2024, international enrolments have typically regrown well to 80% or more of 2019 levels, these issues are worth revisiting:


·           During the Covid lockdown/border closure period, the loss of international revenues could have been lessened by using student accommodation as MIQ facilities for vaccinated students, and perhaps by building low-cost decentralised MIQ housing outside our main centres at locations such as military bases. The Government did not want to consider such options.


·           The missing revenue from students spending in the community hastened the demise of small retail businesses – rows of deserted shop premises in Queen Street, Auckland, were sorry reminders of this economic damage.


·           Students enrolled for on-line courses do not bring to New Zealand the economic multiplier revenue arising from their living in the community. Around two-thirds of the associated total economic benefit is lost.


·           Many university staff have been subsequently laid off or taken voluntary severance, for example announced staff reductions at Otago University (107), Victoria University of Wellington (229), and Massey University (at least 140). AUT announced that up to 230 jobs could go but the redundancy process was put on hold, with a smaller number taking voluntary severance. Some private tertiary institutions had to severely curtail their operations or close. The thousands of person-years of teaching and research experience lost to NZ have been damaging to the scope and quality of our taught degree and research programmes.


·           Across Computer Science, Engineering and Mathematics, at AUT in 2019 international students made up over 28% of undergraduate and Masters enrolments, and 73% of PhD enrolments. These proportions are broadly indicative of the sector. To maintain the international ranking of our universities, and our national research performance, these international postgraduate enrolments must be rebuilt to pre-Covid levels, not least because Science and Engineering graduates continue to be in high demand in our high-tech industry sector. 


·           The USA, Canada, the UK, and Australia re-opened their international student business ahead of New Zealand (no surprise there!) seizing a market advantage which slowed the recovery in our international enrolments and delivered New Zealand a mid-term economic penalty. 


·           International students enrich cross-cultural connections and understanding at our secondary and tertiary institutions. This is something to value and maintain.


·           The Colombo Plan which ran from 1950 to 1983 brought hundreds of students to New Zealand from South, North and Southeast Asia.  Malaysia was a notable example.  Colombo Plan graduates from our universities worked their way into senior Government and business roles in their home countries but retained a strong affection for New Zealand and helped build reciprocal trade. Many sent their own children to study in this country. These ties raised New Zealand’s profile internationally and delivered economic benefits far beyond just those from the historical connections.


Source countries for international students such as China increasingly provide university education for their own students, but we should nonetheless intensively rebuild international education in New Zealand, but with an eye on the future sustainable size of this business, probably not more than around 20% of all enrolments. International student business is volatile and very vulnerable to geo-political and economic events.  We need to think about how to make this business more resilient without simply choosing to cap it at a modest size. 


Perhaps this will be partly through a mix of on-line and in-country enrolments that will benefit both the economy and our wider society. Ideally there should be less reliance on a couple of countries - in 2019, 37% of international students were from China and 22% from India. To deal with the volatility risk, universities could be required to do something like putting 5-10% of their international revenue into an “insurance” fund, accessible only in the event of a major market downturn to buffer the system against the loss of large numbers of staff that would otherwise take a long time to rebuild.

We should see this as a long game, and enduring links with New Zealand forged by a new generation of international graduates will boost our future international relations and trade.


A key part of building resilience is to have a Government Immigration Department that has the breadth and depth of expertise to offer rapid and effective response to student visa applications.  A slow response means that students accept places at universities in other countries.


How is it that, when Public Service employee numbers ballooned from 48,000 to over 64,000 between 2017 and 2023, Immigration New Zealand has not recruited and trained sufficient staff to manage the well-anticipated volume of international student visa applications?  We can do better than this.  Let’s get cracking and remove any roadblocks to faster re-growth of this high value export industry.

 

John Raine is an Emeritus Professor of Engineering who held Pro Vice Chancellor or Deputy Vice Chancellor roles in three New Zealand universities.  He formerly had responsibility for international student operations and international relations at Massey University and the University of Canterbury.


This is an edited version of an article that first appeared in Breaking Views NZ.

 

2,042 views49 comments

49 comentarios


commenting as Johanna

Time to stop the acquisition of more so called 'investment' property .

Time to sell those investments to fund the universities education delivery shortfall.

Victoria Uni apparently bought the Teachers Training College and campus in Karori from the government for a $1 then flicked it on to the retirement sector for $18 million.

Where did that money go?

Time to have an audit of all university assets and a very stringent assessment of its acquisition and disposal decision making.

Time for the taxpayer to hold all the universities to account for mismanagement and self serving aggrandizement. Along with wink, wink, nod, nod ceremonies of sycophantic rewards/ benevolence, awarding 'honorary stuff and nonsense degrees' to the likes …

Me gusta

caarnott
caarnott
23 mar

I read today about the Cloward-Piven strategy: It is a political strategy outlined in 1966 by American sociologists and political activists Richard Cloward and Frances Fox Piven. It is the strategy of forcing political change leading to societal collapse through orchestrated crises. The "C-P strategy" seeks to hasten the fall of capitalism by overloading the government bureaucracy with a flood of impossible demands, amassing massive unpayable national debt, and other methods such as unfettered immigration thus pushing society into crisis and economic collapse by overwhelming the country. (This was referring to the US but it has occurred world wide. Look where the world is now.


The whole point of this article was to point out that Wikipedia has just changed…

Me gusta
Contestando a

"Wikipedia has just changed"

It's like climate change ; it's constant.

Me gusta

This stupid and prolonged lock down idiocy that pervaded new Zealand wasn't just confined to the universities.

Good people,,able people, from overseas, able and willing, were locked out of the trades and it truly became dog eat dog territory with the talent available.

It was horrific watching it happen,

The last government has the undying legacy of closeminded stupidity and willful ignorance on its books, worn as a badge of dishonor, worn by those that were all to happy to put idealism and ideology over the best for new Zealand and care about nothing else than their own legacy.

The damage done at every level, to all sectors of the useful and the productive , perpetrated needlessly upon us b…


Me gusta
Contestando a

MEME: I'm from the government & I'm here to help!

Me gusta

In reply to various comments, see earlier articles of mine and co-authors on this site. I agree with criticisms about our universities having lost their way with massive administrations and high expenditure in areas that support critical social justice/DEI agendas, which themselves have damaged the university sector throughout the western world and in NZ. There needs to be a rerfocus on freedom of speech, merit and excellence unrelated to personal identity or ethnicity. The university financial model sector is also due for a major reappraisal, as the universities have become too dependent on international student revenue, partly through government funding having fallen by about 40% relative to inflation over the past 25 years or so.. There are also many…

Me gusta
Contestando a

Fair comment, and apologies if any comments (including mine) were a bit blunt. Your articles have always been much appreciated, I think the topic of this one probably pushed a few buttons as the effect of mass foreign students flows into so many more areas other than just economic benefit from the students. Which there clearly is. And universities most obviously chased that market. And yes, they spend money while here. Your point about building future relationships was an excellent one and not something I had previously considered, so thanks for that.'


I guess the issues arise when something is over cooked and greed takes over. Private companies have also driven this sector and profited handsomely from huge numbers o…


Me gusta

Everyone should know the value of university assets before they come begging for more taxpayer funding. Victoria University should publish the property they own in Wellington.

Me gusta
Contestando a

So you reckon that Victoria should sell off its buildings to fund its operations. Weĺl, I suppose they could always continue the lectures in Kelburn Park.

Me gusta
bottom of page