top of page

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Search

PETER WILLIAMS: End Judicial Activism

Judicial activism is showing no signs of slowing down, and it’s a stain on our society.


If you have any fraction of Maori in your bloodline, it is, according to a Family Court judge, “necessary to consider familial, community and cultural matters which are inherent in the development of the identity of a Maori child. These considerations are different from those for a Pakeha child.”


If you’re concerned about the growing level of tension in race relations in this country, look no further than those appalling words from Family Court judge Jill Moss.


How can a member of our judiciary state that Maori are different from non-Maori and say that some children in New Zealand need a different kind of upbringing to others?


What’s more this judge says the obligation to consider those “familial, community and cultural matters” arose from the Treaty of Waitangi.


That is insulting and arrant nonsense.


Which Article of the Treaty says some New Zealanders should be treated differently to others?


Even those with just a rudimentary knowledge of the Treaty understand the three Articles: 1 - the Chiefs ceded the right to govern to the Crown, 2 - Maori would retain ownership and control over their lands and other property, and 3 - all New Zealanders would become British subjects.


It is in Article Three that the concept of “all the ordinary people of New Zealand” having the “same rights and duties of citizenship as the people of England” is clearly spelled out.


How can a learned judge of the Family Court re-interpret a much studied document of 183 years ago and find that some ordinary people of New Zealand have different rights and duties?


This whole Family Court debacle came about after a gay female couple wanted a child and decided for reasons best known to themselves to have a Maori sperm donor.


The complication came when the mother and the sperm donor signed an agreement allowing the donor to have a role in the child’s life.


Bad, bad mistake.


If you’re female and gay and want a child, keep the father anonymous and out of both your life, and the life of the child. It’s much less complicated.


In this case the relationship between the mother and the sperm donor fell apart, yet the donor wanted not just to be part of his daughter’s life but also insisted that “she be aware of her identity and proud of her heritage.”


A psychologist’s report quoted the sperm donor father as saying his daughter needed “urgent attention to matters relating to her identity and a defined sense of belonging within her whanau.” The psychologist went on to assert “that approach does not accord with Eurocentric social science theory.”


In the end the Judge decided this sperm donor father can see his daughter once every three weeks. The young girl is currently five years old. I despair of the confusing upbringing she will have.


But I despair more at the insults that educated people are throwing at my non-Maori, or if you like Pakeha, culture. I’ve always led a way of life where family connections are paramount and where we all have a sense of belonging.


I’m deeply offended that a Family Court judge says that Maori children should have different considerations than those for a Pakeha child, and that a psychologist believes “Eurocentric social science theory” (whatever the hell that is) does not include a sense of belonging inside a family.


It is time academics in ivory towers stopped praising Maori and whanau life as superior to the rest of us.


It is not.


We are all New Zealanders. We all have, under Article Three of the Treaty the ”same rights and duties of citizenship.”


It is time to stop the insults and the division. It will ease the tension.



Writer and broadcaster for half a century. Now watching from the sidelines. Subscribe to Peter William's Substack here

 
 
 

99 Comments


This comment was deleted.
JW
JW
Nov 25, 2023
Replying to

The brevity of the treaty is what has led to it being interpreted over the years by the judicial system. While many want to put a stop to this, the government of the day set up the Waitangi Tribunal to interpret it and nobody has proposed a different group. I think a degree of equality was intended in the treaty, hence its description as “akin to a partnership”

Edited
Like

fozmex
fozmex
Nov 23, 2023

You can blame the likes of Chris Finlayson and his ilk, that have gone before for all this insanity.


What kind of craziness has this country come to when we afford all the legal rights of a person to rivers and mountains?


We've all gone mad.


Like
Stuart MacGregor
Stuart MacGregor
Nov 24, 2023
Replying to

I think he went back to working for Maori against the government.

Like

This comment was deleted.
charliecovkid7491
Dec 05, 2023
Replying to

Huge generalisations. It's not one size fits all. Like autism , there are many , many variations. Similarly autism or dyslexia. We are all on the spectrum somewhere.

I wonder why you used the term as an insult ? Coupled with inaccurate information.

Like

richard stuart
richard stuart
Nov 21, 2023

If we are going down the identity route then we would have to insist on DNA tests for all as a way of proving that one has a special privilege, and at what percentage are we to draw the cut-off? A parent with a 50% Maori could be allowed special status, whereas their children and spouse would perhaps not, which would lead to ridiculous results as in a parent would be allowed in a hospital but the child not. I can imagine a scenario where every organisation which gives special privilege (universities, councils, police, health authorities, courts etc.) would be required to see the DNA certificate which again is oppresive.


The alternative is to accept self-identification. If this happens the…


Like
WWalter
Dec 06, 2023
Replying to

New research has carbon-dated the arrival of Māori settlers to as early as the 13th century. If we could only find carbon dated proof of inhabitation of NZ earlier than the 13th century to corroborate oral recollections.

Edited
Like

Viking Al
Nov 21, 2023

I agree with the comments here, however I am feeling a lot better since the elections as I read the panic setting in from the usual outspoken elite Māori who for too long have been lining their pockets with taxpayers money and now see their personal gravy train coming to the end of its journey.

Like
harveyandsara
harveyandsara
Nov 25, 2023
Replying to

Yes. It was amazing how the mood of the nation rose as the coalition deal was announced. It is obvious that Act and Nz first have forced the National party into needing to do a whole lot more than they probably would have liked .Here's hoping the hold Nationals feet to flame throughout this govt cycle.

Like

©2021 by Bassett, Brash & Hide. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page