top of page

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Search

Public Health, Private Pain

There is something madly wrong with Public Health.

It’s been apparent for some years but has come to the fore with Covid.

The problems are illustrated in a short blog post on Climate Change written by six Public Health professionals including Profs Michael Baker and Nick Wilson.


It’s characteristic of Public Health that a short post has six authors. I suspect it’s to corral the faculty and add weight.


Public Health presents as monolithic with dissent squashed. Here’s distinguished professor Ian Reid on emeritus professor Des Gorman: “Des has no role in representing our department on the subject of Covid or others”. Professor Reid makes clear that he as department head is the final arbiter of the Department’s view. It’s astonishing that a department has a collective view let alone one that must be represented. That alone shows the deplorable state of the discipline.


Having multiple authors not only corrals the faculty but also gives fake weight to pronouncements. In the absence of facts and reason, Public Health relies upon expert agreement. 'It’s true because we experts agree it’s true.'

Public Health experts have always exhorted us to do one thing or another. But whereas it was once to floss and to breast feed it is now to engage in politics. The authors' purpose is to encourage us to make a submission on the Climate Commission’s report backing the Public Health experts’ pronouncement. “[T]here is still time to influence its final report”. Make a submission. Support what we say. There are six of us. We are experts. We stand for Public Health.


And the point? The Climate Commission hasn’t given sufficient weight to the Health Benefits of going Net Zero.

According to the Six, reducing fossil fuel use and planting trees would make us spend more time in the salad section and less time in meat and dairy. That’s supposedly good for us and good for the planet. Meat and dairy are priced out of the shopping basket: we can eat broccoli and salads instead.


Taxing fossil fuels would also mean less car and truck use and therefore less pollution. We would bike and walk more. We would be fitter and leaner.


Net Zero would thereby make us live longer and healthier. We would eat less meat and dairy, we would bike and walk more, and the air would be fresher. It would be wonderful.


The Six also write that Net Zero would make the country fairer and honour Te Tiriti. The Six don’t explain how Net Zero does this. They just add equity and Te Tiriti to pump the policy. That happens a lot in Public Health.


The Six also say we would be happier at Net Zero. It requires considerable hubris to decide what makes us happier but that’s not a problem for Public Health experts.


In summary, centrally directing the economy, defuelling industry and covering the countryside in trees will make us healthier, happier, longer living, equitable and honour Te Tiriti. There’s no cost or upset, no tradeoff or downside. Net Zero delivers happiness and peace.


Of course, there’s no rigour or intellectual heft with any of this. The Green Party’s manifesto makes more sense.


And if you doubt our Public Health experts, here's their kicker argument:


"The commission should also build on the experience of New Zealand’s successful response to the COVID-19 pandemic. This response has shown the benefits of rapid, science-informed and vigorous all-of-government action — and delivered public health and economic benefits."

For these experts, the last year-and-a-half has delivered health and economic benefits. That's all you need know about how madly wrong they are. And Covid’s just the start. We now have Net Zero to look forward to.

Public Health experts are so out of whack they need a health warning.


 
 
 

52 Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
Jim Dowsett
Jim Dowsett
Oct 07, 2021

Were the 6 Professors dresses in Clown Outfits for their presentation?

Like

"There is something madly wrong with Public Health", we all experience it, all who work in the field of health care experience it, do you remember that nurses were just about to strike when this Covid outbreak started and here we have six Public Health professionals who seriously think that the way how to improve our health is to impose on us more restrictions this time from the Climate Change basket. And who is responsible for the shortage of hospital beds, ICUs, ventilators, doctors, nusrses, medicines etc.? What did they do for 18 months we have lived with Covid to improve the system so that we would be able to cope with the outbreak without lockdowns? Where were their voices…


Like

badger
Sep 27, 2021

I'm guessing "increased physical activity" is when all of us poor people get to walk the 7km to Mitre 10 to pick up our bags of compost?

Like

winder44
winder44
Sep 27, 2021

I am starting to lose faith in the human race. Probably because I have too much time on my hands during this level 4 lockdown. Sorry, Level 3 with greater restrictions, but you can get takeaways. I cannot believe that fast food takes such a huge importance in somebody's life that they will queue up for it at midnight, or 4am in the morning to buy a product that is basically overpriced, and not exactly healthy by any food standard.

Gasoline at $2.35 lt. and the incredible number of car breakdowns reported each day.

I was under the impression that staying at home was expected unless travel was essential. I live on one of the urban route roads. On Sunday…

Like
ron
ron
Sep 27, 2021
Replying to

"I am starting to lose faith in the human race."

Likewise, I'm starting to believe in human devolution.

Like

Octavian Augustus
Octavian Augustus
Sep 27, 2021

They may have some letters next to their names in order to fill in any gaps in their arguments, but these people are just mouthpieces for the power structure, whose task is to lend a thin veneer of independence and legitimacy to the predetermined decisions of their pay masters. They are prostitutes and salesmen, not scientists in any true sense of the word.

Like
ron
ron
Sep 27, 2021
Replying to

Possibly a wee bit disrespectful to 'prostitutes and salesmen', who no doubt mostly do an honest job at what they do.

Like

©2021 by Bassett, Brash & Hide. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page