top of page

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Search

RODNEY HIDE: Sex v Gender

It’s a simple question: is a man who wants to be a woman a transvestite or an actual woman?


The gender ideology rampant in our schools, workplaces and our politics is that men who want to be a woman are actual women. Our entire parliament voted unanimously to enable birth certificates to be corrected retrospectively. Both mum and doctor were wrong in declaring baby a boy on what hitherto had been an obvious determinant.


Their mistake is to be corrected, and corrected without acknowledgement that the birth certificate has been changed.


Gender identity now has no relationship to sex. Gender is fluid and a spectrum and we each have a potentially ever-changing gender soul somewhere deep inside us telling us which of many dozen genders we are at any moment.


Our chromosomes and reproductive organs play no role in deciding whether we are a man or a woman or some other identity. We self-declare our identity to be our true selves based not on biology but our gender soul.


Let’s be clear: this is not about inclusivity or being respectful to all men and women however they choose to live their life.


It’s not about disrespecting men who choose to dress and behave as women. They enjoy the same rights that I do. It’s just the recognition that they are biologically men, not women. We can’t pretend they are women and thereby disrespect all girls and women and destroy their sport and private safe spaces. It’s one or the other. We either accept transvestites as women, and erase women, or we respect transvestites as men who choose to live as women and preserve women.


Gender ideology is the idea that there is no definition of a woman or a man. There is no biology. There is no biblical teaching. There is just you, discovering yourself, deep inside. It is about the blurring of any distinction between men and women and, indeed, the erasure of both men and women.


Gender ideology is teaching 8, 9, 10 year olds that the label 'boy' or 'girl' is a social construct and that they need to dig deep and open themselves up to their true self which may be that they are a girl not a boy, or vice versa, or something else entirely.


It is not healthy for young people to be told a basic reality is not true. It is not helpful to have their teachers teach a lie that is obviously a lie to many of them and their parents. It’s destructive to label a little girl who blurts out, “But a girl is a girl” a transphobe to the jeers and taunts of her classmates and teachers.


The children “coming out” at primary school are declared brave and accorded special treatment. They are encouraged to be something other than the sex they are.


Children quickly learn to conform and to keep their thoughts to themselves or to banish them as clearly wrong and their parents old-fashioned in thinking sex is binary and that there is a difference between XX and XY.


The majority of people appear blissfully unaware of the monstrosity of the problem. Witness National Party leader Chris Luxon saying he was not going to talk about toilets and those worried about who was gaining access to hitherto girls’ and womens’ only places were on another planet.


He hasn’t had daughters refusing to go to the toilet all day at school because of the boys or of being confused and alarmed as nine years old by a grown man with a beard appearing in the girls’ changing shed.


There is even a darker feature of gender ideology, if that is even possible.


It is the violence exacted on any one who disagrees. We saw that in Albert Park earlier this year at the rally Let Women Speak where women including the elderly were physically attacked while the police looked on unwilling to help. The women wanting to speak were declared nazi-adjacent by our politicians and media simply for wishing to defend women as women and their spaces. Anyone questioning gender ideology is shouted down loudly and, ultimately, violently.


There is also discipline and re-education for those who refuse to comply.


Here is one example of how deeply gender ideology is embedded in our organisations. Policy Advisor Emma Barraclough was urged by her Ministry of Transport CEO to attend a talk by the advocacy group InsideOUT. The talk at MOT was “How to Connect with the Rainbow Community”.


The flashpoint became whether Emma’s lesbian family member should accept a man who identifies as a woman as a lover. The ideology is firmly yes. These men are women. To not accept them is transphobic and, I assume, nazi-adjacent.


Here is the recorded exchange:


IO: Saying male is part of the problem. We ascribe genders and meanings to bodies that are socially constructed. It’s interesting you focused on penis. It’s part of the narrative that transwomen are a threat to cisgender women.


EB – no, she would say that she is same-sex attracted.


IO: We live and grow up with different generational understandings. That isn’t how our rangatahi [young people] would use that language. We hear from them that they identify as lesbians because they are attracted to women. It's less about someone’s sex characteristics and more about the gender of that person.


EB: I think that gets rid of same-sex attraction. Which to her - and me - is denying homosexuality. If you are saying that a lesbian should consider having a relationship with someone that is male bodied – I accept that you disagree with that term but if you are distinguishing between gender and sex we can talk about sex characteristics – then that means that lesbians should be open to having relationships with people who are male bodied, which to me seems... [I tailed off here, somewhat lost for words]


IO: Maybe it’s based on your [relative’s] understanding and that’s her journey, her narrative. But transwomen are women so they need to be included in lesbian communities. They are women. But she can have her own preferences. That’s her prerogative. But it’s important that we shouldn’t erase transwomen from those communities because they are women.


Two weeks later Emma received a letter from her Deputy Chief Executive which, following complaint, was backed by her Chief Executive:



"At the presentation … you asked me if I would allow extra time to enable you to ask the presenter a question. I was surprised and disappointed that you chose to use that opportunity to inappropriately challenge the presenter, [Name], and the highly informative presentation she had given us.


It was concerning to me and others that you persistently used language to describe trans women such as 'male-bodied', even after [Name] explained that such language is inappropriate and offensive. Since the presentation I have been advised that a number of other attendees were also offended and shocked by your behaviour.”


And there you have it. To say lesbians are same-sex attracted females is inappropriate and offensive. It is wrong-think.


It is wrong-think at the Ministry of Transport, all government departments, all corporations, all universities and all schools.


Our primary school children are taught that they could be born in the wrong body but also that it is inappropriate and offensive to describe someone as male-bodied or female-bodied.


Sex is nothing. Gender is everything. And you get to choose. And every one of our 120 MPs voted to enable each and every one of us to change the sex on our birth certificate to our chosen identity.


The resulting confusion and, indeed, trauma, inflicted on pre-pubescent boys and girls is making our schools toxic. And Mr Luxon doesn’t want to talk about it. And those brave women who do speak out are violently attacked while our police look on proud of their Rainbow Tick and their inclusiveness.



See https://www.speakupforwomen.nz/post/the-day-insideout-came-to-the-ministry-of-transport






4,446 views144 comments

144 Comments


Since the gender ideology promotes the idea of a conflict between biological sex and identified gender it does not make any logical sense to ONLY affirm the gender part of the conflict and NOT the biological. After all the biological is intrinsic and very difficult to overcome. Surgery doesn't resolve it, it just makes the pretense less obvious. Whereas the gender identification is a psychological issue much more easily addressed.

Clearly Marxist psy-ops. Do not give it any credence at all.

Like

Just to answer a few questions that have come up here.


How did we come to this?? In Nz in particular, we seem to have imported all sorts of transgender loudmouths who have done very well out of taking public money and ramming this ideology down everyone's throat. Similarly we have imported the Paul Hunt's and Mohan Dutta's (+ many more) of the progessive world to be thought leaders influencing our young people and our society. Heck we even made the pernicious Shaneel Lal - young NZer of the year.


On top of that we deplatformed even small gatherings of women who wanted to talk about this going back a whole eight? years and happening over and over again. Newspaper…


Like

rdglawrence
rdglawrence
Oct 05, 2023

What an interesting article Rodney. Accordingly, as I’m attracted to women, using this analogy I must be a lesbian, not a red blooded heterosexual male.

Thanks for that.

Like

Aaron Shanahan
Aaron Shanahan
Oct 05, 2023

For Christ's sake. A biological man is a man.

A biological women is a women.

2 sexs. End of list.

I've no issue at all with a person that wants to change gender.

But gender change isn't biologically possible, so the next best thing is for those to that make that step, to themselves, is to make a construct of rights for themselves to reaffirm their gender change, enabled by the big fucking lie.

Identifying as anything other than what you physically are does not make anyone who identifies as the entity they are not .

To transgender males especially?

Look. Good luck to you.

That's a big bloody leap of fate you've taken , but if that's how you…


Like

zekewulfe
zekewulfe
Oct 04, 2023

Rodney Hide Quote:


Sex is nothing. Gender is everything. And you get to choose. And every one of our 120 MPs voted to enable each and every one of us to change the sex on our birth certificate to our chosen identity.

FFS......What size can of worms is being opened here ? and to think we sent them there to make wise decisions


So I will say it again ..... did I miss something ? or is everyone of them F...ed in the head

Like
Replying to

Yes, these people are seriously deluded and are causing the rest of the people to accept their delusions.

Like
bottom of page