top of page

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Search

STEPHEN FRANKS: Press seek to publicly shame doctor. We must push back.

The following is a message from lawyer Stephen Franks on behalf of the Free Speech Union.


I don’t like to interrupt first thing Monday morning, but we've just become aware of a case where we think immediate and overwhelming attention could help turn the tide. It involves someone I’ve long followed on Twitter with the handle @MomoStJohn.


I followed Momo because of tweets that seemed reassuringly well-informed on issues raised by anti-vaxxers and others suspicious of conventional medicine. There were also many sensible comments and corrections in debates about the collapse of morale and service capacity in our health system. I’ve just learned that she is a senior practitioner and is employed by Te Whatu Ora.


Momo needs your help.


But helping to protect her from media and employer oppression could also help turn the tide in favour of other health sector people who want to be able to tell the truth without fear of cancellation.


___________________________________________________________________________________


For years, Momo has had an anonymous Twitter account where she could express thoughts on issues without causing what employers could claim was embarrassment, and to avoid trouble for colleagues. She needed to keep her identity confidential.


Over years of seeing her tweets, I remember nothing offensive. Her opinions seemed informed and interesting. Sometimes they were blunt (i.e expressed crisply) but Twitter is not a medium for pompous euphemisms.

From what we explain below, there may have been support for gender-critical feminism (perhaps the view that “what is a woman” has had a simple answer since forever) and probably some expression of the widespread medical professional revulsion at rationing medical care on the basis of race, instead of clinical need and usefulness. I recall nothing that any rational professional should be ashamed of.

But last week, someone complained to Te Whatu Ora that Momo was saying things they disagreed with. I saw Momo’s announcement that she was closing her twitter account and then scores of followers tweeting best wishes and regret at the loss.

A journalist at Stuff, Jody O'Callahan 'with a focus on Maori affairs and diversity' found out who Momo was and sent this message:




'Issues with your social media activity' should read: 'We've found 'wrongthink' on your anonymous account.' Then, two fake questions which are essentially dodgy allegations around statements assuming guilt.


The message is nothing more than 'We are going to publicly denounce you.'


The fake questions are framed to allow the branding of any careful and accurate answer as denialism, or equivocation, in the classic 'have you stopped beating your wife?' genre.


In response, Momo released a statement which read:





What's the story here?


If there is any story to follow O’Callaghan’s fake questions, they must depend on one or more of the following:


(1) The idea that it is “unsafe” to allow doctors to practice if they still believe in the science they learned and rely on, which denies that men can become women if they want; or


(2) It may be safe to allow doctors to practice while not believing in the new ruling dogma on gender as long as they never express their doubts about the new faith publicly; or


(3) That someone who believes that racism in rationing healthcare is wrong will be dangerous to patients who would ‘benefit’ from getting a race pass to the front of the queue; or


(4) There is nevertheless some technique or way for a doctor who believes that racism in health care is wrong to “ensure” that their opposition to racism won’t “sway how” [they] treat [their] patients.”


All the likely interpretations of the fake questions make them disgracefully silly for the journalist 'asking' them.


In reality, the story is a story only for those believe it is OK for employers to use their power to stop doctors working if they don’t believe, or at least pretend to believe, in the recently imposed Wellington official faiths in race preferences and non-binary gender.





This is a very dangerous takeover of state powers. It treats the idea of the tolerant secular state, which drove the NZ Bill of Rights Act protections of freedom of opinion and freedom of speech, as quaint anachronisms – to be ignored.


Ms Callaghan and her enablers in Stuff need to answer some questions themselves – genuine ones this time.


“Are doctors not allowed to have opinions themselves? What opinions are forbidden? What if until recently discrimination was considered wrong? At what stage should people with newly-'sinful' views be considered to have become dangerous? Who will decide? Have you asked the patients – what if they still want doctors who have the courage to resist ideolo]gical bullies? Have you asked if the trans and Maori you pretend to care about should get a choice? As a journalist are you worried if it becomes routine for people to hide their views – because your questions seem to rely on an assumption that things could be fine if the 'sinful' thoughts had been harbored unsaid.”


There are scores more pertinent questions to put to Ms. Callaghan and Stuff.


“Have you another line of views and jobs that can’t be mixed? Where is your evidence that the views you are trying to smoke out, are associated with risks? How will you ensure that your views won't sway and bias the “news” you supply to the people who rely on Stuff to be informed? Are you perpetuating mistrust among those of us who seek objective and factual reporting?"


"We just want to give you your opportunity to have a say.”


You will be able to think of many more.


Now is the time to smoke out the journalists who want to doxx doctors who don't share their totalitarian ideological faith. Please send Ms Callaghan and Stuff your questions. We have written directly with some.


Stuff should not be allowed to get away with doxxing medical staff for 'wrongthink'? Our professionally conducted annual survey of academic freedom shows the pervasive fear now in our Universities; that a career-ending mistake could come from incautious expression of doubt in the current Wellington orthodoxy.


Let’s fight this spread into medicine. Actions like this are why Kiwis self-censor and feel unfree to speak (or think) for themselves. We need to stand up for the right of this medical practitioner to hold opinions others don't like, and push back.


__________________________________________________________________________________


What you can do:


Contact Jody O'Callaghan at jody.ocallaghan@stuff.co.nz. If you're on Twitter, her handle is: @miss_jodyo


Kamala Hayman is also the editor of The Press, which is the Stuff outlet O'Callaghan works for. You can copy her in too: Kamala.hayman@stuff.co.nz. Her Twitter handle is: @kamala_hayman


Remind them that in a free country people like Momo in the caring professions have every right to hold opinions others disagree with, and to express them publicly. Hit jobs like this are the reason many feel like they need to hide behind anonymous accounts on Twitter to say anything at all. Do we wonder why only 42% of Kiwis trust mainstream media?


The Free Speech Union entirely endorses the crucial role of the 4th Estate and the freedom of the press. Media are supposed to perform a vital function to enable free speech and democracy. Yet, actions like those being attempted by O'Callaghan and Stuff are the opposite of this. They now use this freedom to seek out people with diverse thoughts and target them for not holding the approved line.


I hope you will join us today in pushing back against this nonsense.


Stephen Franks

Council Member

Free Speech Union

5,514 views58 comments

58件のコメント


justise xtra
justise xtra
2023年10月03日

The votes of Maori are in favor of National as it functions to do the terms without prejudice regardless how hard the environment is and that families are thinking they are repressed they are allowed to establish the sense of free speech. The problem is the Minister Nanaia Mahuta suggests that the company she keeps for the other side could be as intimidating and so bears no compensation to how people are targeted by the Social Media Brainwash, The operatives in Networks that have troubled all of us inclusive of Security and Intelligence and that the mole who is front and center not only colludes to call out Labour Party is in National Party that is the clear objective of…

いいね!

The trouble is with those who write for stuff, the likes of Tova, Andrea, Paula, Joel Maxwell etc, is that they might have their email addresses on their articles but the never read them and respond. They are truly afraid of being bombarded with opposing opinions. I have written countless emails to the three woman and never once have had a reply. I can’t even find Maxwells , he is well protected from the majority of NZers. He did have a comments section but he’s got rid of that. They are all bullies and cowards.

thanks

Don

いいね!

Good work thanks Stephen. They’re a pack of bloody fascists!

いいね!

Aaron Shanahan
Aaron Shanahan
2023年9月26日

Whether its one news, newshub, newsroom , stuff or anyone of the socialist malaise driven opinion sites that exists to spout marxit mantra as truth, I have had a fucking titfull of their continual hand writhing around in my wallet for espousing shit street level journalistic rubbish as something I should listen to and take seriously.

Now this fucking bullshit garbage stops.

And it stops now.

Immediately defund and scrap public service broadcasting at every level, and let those who have a hard earned Dollar to invest on a hard earned voice to make the paycheck happen because their audience is based on listenership, not automatic funding .

I'm not prepared, any longer, to to fund a public purse tha…


いいね!
返信先

So... you're not happy with the mainstream media? Why not just say! Stop beating around the bush.

いいね!

James G Cooke
James G Cooke
2023年9月26日

Update on the open letter to Stuff...


No response.


So in order to assist the good people at Stuff I helpfully sent Muriel Newman's summation of the state of our media (https://www.nzcpr.com/undue-influence/), to Kamala Hayman and gave them until 2pm today to respond to Muriel's commentary before I post this follow up.


To aid in Kamala's understanding of the position they put Momo in I (helpfully) suggested she might also like to add a statement about what it feels like to be exposed in this manner and how she is going to make changes within Stuff to improve balance and impartiality amongst their writers.


Unfortunately 2pm came and went, so thinking it might be they are based in another time…


いいね!
bottom of page